Three Types of Acne Scars on One Face: Why There Is No Fixed Treatment Order
A single face can have ice pick scars, boxcar scars, and rolling scars at the same time. The doctor does not follow a fixed sequence of treatments, but builds a plan based on the structure of the scars and the clinical examination.

The doctor does not follow one fixed sequence for everyone. Instead, the plan is built from an examination of each person's scar type, depth, number, location, and any active acne.
Quick summary:
- One person can have several types of atrophic scars at the same time, such as ice pick, boxcar, and rolling scars, in different areas of the face.
- There is no fixed treatment sequence for every case. If acne is flaring, controlling the acne is usually done first.
- The treatment plan should combine an assessment of tissue structure, depth, and surface texture rather than relying on a single device.
Three Types of Acne Scars Appearing Together on One Face
According to the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD), it is entirely possible to have more than one type of atrophic acne scar. In practice, you may see three main types of lesions coexisting:
- Ice pick scars: Small, deep pits with a narrow opening that extends far down into the skin.
- Rolling scars: Wide, shallow scars that give the skin a wavy, undulating surface.
- Boxcar scars: Round or oval depressions with well-defined edges, wider than ice pick scars but narrower than rolling scars.
Besides these scars, flat areas of discoloration left on the skin after acne are not necessarily atrophic scars. Because each scar type differs markedly in depth and shape, the doctor cannot apply the same single approach to the whole face.
Short video: the doctor consults on a case of mixed scars that requires a combination of laser, peels, and subcision.
Key point: The doctor explains that mixed scars require a combination of laser, peels, and subcision to treat atrophic scars.
Controlling Active Acne Before Treating Scars
When deciding the order of treatment, the first factor the doctor assesses is the current level of inflammation. The AAD notes that if acne is flaring, treatment usually begins with acne control to reduce inflammation and prevent new scars from forming.
Treating skin with acute inflammation can not only hinder the improvement of scar tissue but may also cause further damage. Stabilizing acne activity is therefore the foundational priority before moving on to targeted treatment for each type of scar.

Assessing Structure, Depth, and Surface Instead of Relying on One Device
Many people looking for acne scar treatment expect a single technological device to solve everything. However, the medical approach focuses on analyzing the anatomical characteristics of each lesion:
- Connection to the underlying tissue: The AAD states that subcision (surgical release) can be used to lift some scars away from the underlying tissue; the doctor must examine you to determine whether this applies to a specific scarred area.
- Shape and depth: Ice pick scars are small but deep, while rolling scars are wider and shallower. This difference is why the same method cannot be used for every scar.
- Number and location: The plan must also consider scar density and the affected areas of skin, rather than choosing a method based only on the name of a machine.
A personalized plan requires considering all of these factors together: scar type, number of depressions, distribution across the face, age, skin tone, and your goals. The doctor will therefore combine the appropriate tools for each area rather than relying on a single device.
Treatment Options for Each Type of Lesion
The AAD notes that atrophic scars may require more than one treatment to achieve improvement. The options the AAD lists include:
- Subcision (surgical release): Lifts a scar away from the underlying tissue, which helps release the tethering of the scar to deeper tissue.
- Chemical peels and laser resurfacing: Act on the layers of the skin to help smooth the surface and improve texture.
- Fillers: Temporarily add volume beneath the base of a depressed scar.
- Microneedling, radiofrequency, and PRP: Options listed by the AAD; whether they are used alone or in combination depends on an examination.
- Dermabrasion: Helps address surface irregularities in the superficial layer.
Ice pick scars and rolling scars may need different approaches, so the doctor will plan the treatment steps according to each person's tissue response rather than following a rigid template.

Recovery and Aftercare
After some scar treatments, such as TCA CROSS, CO2 laser, or subcision, swelling or bruising may appear on the skin. Small scabs or flaking skin may peel off after about 4–7 days.
This recovery course varies considerably depending on the method used and each person's skin characteristics. Home care should follow the instructions of your treating doctor closely so that your recovery can be monitored in line with the procedure performed.
References
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a standard treatment sequence for scars that applies to everyone?
No. The AAD does not provide a fixed sequence or a fixed combination formula for every case. The doctor will build an individual plan based on each person's scar type, number, location, skin tone, and level of inflammation.
If my skin has both scars and inflamed acne, how is it handled?
If acne is flaring, the plan usually begins with acne control to reduce inflammation and prevent new scars from forming before scar treatment begins.
Is flat discoloration after acne clears up an atrophic scar?
Not necessarily. According to the AAD, flat areas of discoloration after acne are not atrophic scars, and they are fundamentally different in nature from scars that involve a loss of volume.
This content was prepared by the BonBoz Clinic editorial team and cross-checked against the medical sources cited in the article.
This content is for reference only and does not replace an in-person examination and consultation with a doctor.
This article is for reference only and does not replace an in-person examination or a doctor's diagnosis. Actual results vary by individual condition.
